Bridges – Being Brunel http://www.beingbrunel.com The Civil Engineering Blog Sat, 20 Aug 2016 15:22:38 +0000 en-US hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=4.9.9 http://www.beingbrunel.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/cropped-being-brunel-512-1-50x50.png Bridges – Being Brunel http://www.beingbrunel.com 32 32 Engineering Is Art: 350 – 399 http://www.beingbrunel.com/engineering-art-350-399/ http://www.beingbrunel.com/engineering-art-350-399/#comments Thu, 02 Jun 2016 11:30:00 +0000 http://www.beingbrunel.com/?p=4213 Being Brunel | The Civil Engineering Blog

#EngineeringIsArt; an excuse to get up every morning and attempt to find a picture that does the built environment, and those who build it, some justice. Having made a return after my hiatus, the #EngineeringIsArt series is an...Read More

The post Engineering Is Art: 350 – 399 appeared first on Being Brunel.

]]>
Being Brunel | The Civil Engineering Blog

#EngineeringIsArt; an excuse to get up every morning and attempt to find a picture that does the built environment, and those who build it, some justice. Having made a return after my hiatus, the #EngineeringIsArt series is an ongoing attempt to celebrate the structure and construction of our infrastructure; rather than just the pretty architecture.

Fancy seeing engineering art daily? Follow Being Brunel on Facebook, Google+ and Twitter.

This is now the eight gallery in the #EngineeringIsArt series. If you haven’t already, you can catch up on numbers 000 to 049, 050 to 099, 100-149, 150-199 , 200-249, 250-299 and 300-349. So, in no particular order, here are pictures 300 to 349; remember engineering is art…



All of the images forming the Engineering Is Art series are Creative Commons licensed; you can find out more about the person who took the photo by following the (Photographer) link on each image caption.

As a non-profit resource itself, Being Brunel employs a lot of Creative Commons material, which you can find out more about on the Attributions page.

The post Engineering Is Art: 350 – 399 appeared first on Being Brunel.

]]>
http://www.beingbrunel.com/engineering-art-350-399/feed/ 1
The Longest Bridges In The UK http://www.beingbrunel.com/longest-bridges-uk/ http://www.beingbrunel.com/longest-bridges-uk/#comments Sun, 15 May 2016 09:45:45 +0000 http://www.beingbrunel.com/?p=3991 Being Brunel | The Civil Engineering Blog

I'll be honest, I was going to do an article about the longest bridges in the world, but it all got very confusing very quickly. So I set my sights lower; the longest bridges in the UK. Some detailed...Read More

The post The Longest Bridges In The UK appeared first on Being Brunel.

]]>
Being Brunel | The Civil Engineering Blog

I’ll be honest, I was going to do an article about the longest bridges in the world, but it all got very confusing very quickly. So I set my sights lower; the longest bridges in the UK. Some detailed research (lit. half hour on Google) has taught me that not only are we missing a queryable data source for our infrastructure, we’re also not really sure how to define how long a bridge is.

For this list I’m settling on defining length as the length the structure is bridging something, rather than largest spans, or spanned obstacle, or one of the other millions of random statistics available about bridges. So without further ado, here are (possibly*) the five longest bridges in the UK.

5. The Forth Road Bridge

Of course, the Forth Road Bridge has to come in fifth! With a total length of 2512m. Unfortunately cable deterioration means it’s being replaced with the Queensferry Crossing (which at 2700m will knock it off this list also)!

4. The QE II Bridge

The Queen Elizabeth II Bridge, or Dartford Toll, was built in 1991 at an impressive 2872m. Opening with the largest cable-stayed span in Europe; and interestingly the only bridge to span the Thames downstream of Tower Bridge.

3. Tay Rail Bridge

Our second Scottish entrant, the Tay Rail Bridge was the second built on that site; replacing the collapsed ‘light weight and low cost’  first attempt. Finished in 1883 it crosses the Firth of Tay with a total length of 3264m.

2. The Second Severn Crossing

In 1996 when the first Severn Bridge was full, they made a second. However the first had already taken the easy route, it had to take a wider, more meandering route, taking this cable stayed beauty to 5128m.

1. The Bromford Viaduct

Depressingly the longest bridge in the UK, weighing in at 5600m, spans Birmingham. The Bromford Viaduct, built in 1964-1972 allows the M6 to flow over the city from Castle Bromwich to Gravelly Hill; encompassing the original Spaghetti Junction!


Kudos to the runners up, the Forth Rail (2467m), Humber (2200m), Severn (1600m), Cromarty (1464m) and Eskine (1321m) Bridges, which aren’t exactly short. *I’m sure there’s a good bit of misinformation online about such things, so feel free to correct me in the comment section; especially if you think my top five are out!

The post The Longest Bridges In The UK appeared first on Being Brunel.

]]>
http://www.beingbrunel.com/longest-bridges-uk/feed/ 4
IABSE Future of Design London 2015 http://www.beingbrunel.com/iabse-future-of-design-london-2015/ http://www.beingbrunel.com/iabse-future-of-design-london-2015/#respond Thu, 13 Aug 2015 10:30:36 +0000 http://www.beingbrunel.com/?p=3887 Being Brunel | The Civil Engineering Blog

What is there to say about the Future of Design conferences that hasn't been said before? Tom has reviewed previous conferences with aplomb and we (as the organising committee for FoD London 2015) are...Read More

The post IABSE Future of Design London 2015 appeared first on Being Brunel.

]]>
Being Brunel | The Civil Engineering Blog

About the Author

David Knight

  • David is a senior engineer at Flint & Neill Ltd, and part of the organising committee for the IABSE Future of Design London conference. He enjoys bridges, bikes, boats and singing, and his girlfriend gets embarrassed when he looks at how handrails are put together in public.
  • Find out more: Twitter

What is there to say about the Future of Design conferences that hasn’t been said before? Tom has reviewed previous conferences with aplomb and we (as the organising committee for FoD London 2015) are aiming to match those heights again. So what do we have in store?

We have Paul Westbury, former CEO of Buro Happold, and now of Laing O’Rourke, talking about why he moved from a major consultancy to the major contractor, and what plans he has for the industry of the future. We have a panel debating whether public money should be spent on private projects. We have an artist and a contractor (Andy Scott and Tim Burton of SH Structures) talking in tandem about the challenges of realising a pair of 30m tall horse heads. We have (new this year!) the judging of a design competition for young designers for a new pedestrian bridge over Bow Creek in East London.

Why should you come? It’s the best opportunity all year to meet other young designers, and to be inspired by the best in the industry. There is a dinner. The tickets are pretty cheap, and it even counts as CPD. It will be held at Imperial College on the 10th September 2015, and tickets are available here.

What else is happening? We have a bit of a focus on materiality – Brian Eckersley (of Eckersley O’Callaghan, winners of the IStructE Supreme Award 2014) talking about structural uses of glass; John O’Mara from Herzog & de Meuron on highest quality concrete; and Frank Meibach talking about some adventurous timber footbridges. Our other panel discussion is looking at why engineers have become invisible – and is this a good thing? And of course we have the best young presenters who have submitted papers for inclusion in the conference.

It’s all set to be an invigorating day. Come, join in, and be inspired.

Go To The IABSE FoD London 2015

The post IABSE Future of Design London 2015 appeared first on Being Brunel.

]]>
http://www.beingbrunel.com/iabse-future-of-design-london-2015/feed/ 0
Engineering Is Art: 300 – 349 http://www.beingbrunel.com/engineering-is-art-300-349/ http://www.beingbrunel.com/engineering-is-art-300-349/#comments Wed, 29 Jul 2015 09:30:44 +0000 http://www.beingbrunel.com/?p=3781 Being Brunel | The Civil Engineering Blog

It seems apt that the official Being Brunel mad-rush season comes to an with this post- as the last-push of daily doubles to get #EngineeringIsArt back on target reaches its head. After today we return to regular, weekly...Read More

The post Engineering Is Art: 300 – 349 appeared first on Being Brunel.

]]>
Being Brunel | The Civil Engineering Blog

It seems apt that the official Being Brunel mad-rush season comes to an with this post- as the last-push of daily doubles to get #EngineeringIsArt back on target reaches its head. After today we return to regular, weekly, blog posts every Thursday and a new photo celebrating the art that is engineering for each weekday. It’s been a fun slog to fulfil my 52 articles/260 pictures a-year quota; but I’ve got a good few side projects that I hope you’ll like that need attention too.

This is now the seventh gallery of the #EngineeringIsArt series; established to prove once and for all that architecture isn’t the final word on artistry in the built environment. If you haven’t already, you can catch up on numbers 000 to 049, 050 to 099, 100-149, 150-199 , 200-249 and 250-299. So, in no particular order, here are pictures 300 to 349; remember engineering is art…

All of the images forming the Engineering Is Art series are Creative Commons licensed; you can find out more about the person who took the photo by following the (Photographer) link on each image caption.

As a non-profit resource itself, Being Brunel employs a lot of Creative Commons material, which you can find out more about on the Attributions page.

The post Engineering Is Art: 300 – 349 appeared first on Being Brunel.

]]>
http://www.beingbrunel.com/engineering-is-art-300-349/feed/ 3
Engineering Is Art: 250 – 299 http://www.beingbrunel.com/engineering-is-art-250-299/ http://www.beingbrunel.com/engineering-is-art-250-299/#comments Tue, 07 Jul 2015 10:00:01 +0000 http://www.beingbrunel.com/?p=3579 Being Brunel | The Civil Engineering Blog

Over a year ago, I decided that I had too much spare time, and though "let's find an engineering picture for every workday". The purpose is long forgotten, but who needs a reason to enjoy some...Read More

The post Engineering Is Art: 250 – 299 appeared first on Being Brunel.

]]>
Being Brunel | The Civil Engineering Blog

Over a year ago, I decided that I had too much spare time, and though “let’s find an engineering picture for every workday”. The purpose is long forgotten, but who needs a reason to enjoy some of the amazing photos the fantastic people share with us on flickr? And while the updates have been a bit sporadic of late, I’ve still somehow managed to hit 300.

This is now the sixth gallery to come from the #EngineeringIsArt series. If none of these 50 images reinstates your stability; you can always look back on 000 to 049, 050 to 099, 100-149, 150-199 and 200-249. So finally, here are pictures 250 to 299 in my ongoing assurance that engineering is art…

All of the images forming the Engineering Is Art series are Creative Commons licensed; you can find out more about the person who took the photo by following the (Photographer) link on each image caption.

As a non-profit resource itself, Being Brunel employs a lot of Creative Commons material, which you can find out more about on the Attributions page.

The post Engineering Is Art: 250 – 299 appeared first on Being Brunel.

]]>
http://www.beingbrunel.com/engineering-is-art-250-299/feed/ 2
Engineering Is Art: 200 – 249 http://www.beingbrunel.com/engineering-is-art-200-249/ http://www.beingbrunel.com/engineering-is-art-200-249/#comments Wed, 18 Mar 2015 12:15:17 +0000 http://www.beingbrunel.com/?p=3446 Being Brunel | The Civil Engineering Blog

Every weekday I stalk the internet for photographs of engineering to share with you all. The purpose is the result of a long forgotten discussion of whether or not engineering is art- to celebrate the...Read More

The post Engineering Is Art: 200 – 249 appeared first on Being Brunel.

]]>
Being Brunel | The Civil Engineering Blog

Every weekday I stalk the internet for photographs of engineering (actually, it’s every two weeks, thanks to the wonderful world of scheduling; but let’s not let the truth stand in the way of a good image) to share with you all. The purpose is the result of a long forgotten discussion of whether or not engineering is art- to celebrate the built environment beyond the aesthetics generated by architecture.

This is the fifth gallery to come from the #EngineeringIsArt series. If none of this 50 image collection compacts your concrete; you can always look back on 000 to 049, 050 to 099, 100-149 and 150-199. And finally, here are pictures 200 to 249 in the undeniable proof that engineering is art…

All of the images forming the Engineering Is Art series are Creative Commons licensed; you can find out more about the person who took the photo by following the (Photographer) link on each image caption.

As a non-profit resource itself, Being Brunel employs a lot of Creative Commons material, which you can find out more about on the Attributions page.

The post Engineering Is Art: 200 – 249 appeared first on Being Brunel.

]]>
http://www.beingbrunel.com/engineering-is-art-200-249/feed/ 1
IABSE Future of Design North 2015 http://www.beingbrunel.com/iabse-future-design-north-2015/ http://www.beingbrunel.com/iabse-future-design-north-2015/#comments Thu, 22 Jan 2015 13:00:58 +0000 http://www.beingbrunel.com/?p=3363 Being Brunel | The Civil Engineering Blog

I can’t tell you how excited I am that tickets for the IABSE Future of Design North 2015 conference are now selling quickly. And sell they should! Some of the most eminent structural engineers and...Read More

The post IABSE Future of Design North 2015 appeared first on Being Brunel.

]]>
Being Brunel | The Civil Engineering Blog

About the Author

Ed Dablin

  • Ed is a recently chartered Senior Engineer working for AECOM in Altrincham with 5 years experience working on a range of bridge projects ranging from long span bridges to rail bridge reconstructions. Outside of work he is a STEM Ambassador and has recently been helping to deliver a number of IABSE events in Manchester.
  • Find out more: LinkedIn

Ed.(itor): What’s that? Another post about an IABSE Future of Design event? Well- what can I say; they’re good events. I’m now a veteran (this’ll be my third), and the mix of young engineers, fascinating presenters, and a chance to rub shoulders with the greats at a decent sit-down dinner makes for the sort of event that reminds you why you became an engineer in the first place.

I can’t tell you how excited I am that tickets for the IABSE Future of Design North 2015 conference are now selling quickly. And sell they should! Some of the most eminent structural engineers and architects will be coming to present at the one day conference being held in Manchester on March 27th.

The conference presents a fantastic opportunity for young professionals like me to get involved. Having been for the first time to the 2014 conference in London last year, it is going to be a must-attend event on my yearly calendar. I met lots of like-minded people in the industry from young designers, celebrated designers to company CEOs. My personal highlight was sitting next to my engineering idol from my whitbybird summer placement days, Mark Whitby, at the evening dinner.

The Young Designers Competition is open to all design professionals and students under 35 and all you need to do to enter is submit a one page paper on some of your innovative work/research. The authors of the 12 papers judged to be the best will be invited to the conference to present for a chance to win prizes and will be awarded a seat at the evening dinner in a most unique setting.

The Line-Up (So far)

There will be two ICE Gold medallists presenting with Dr. Robin Sham (AECOM) travelling all the way from Hong Kong and structural specialist Chris Wise (Expedition) travelling up from London.

There is also a local theme with Brian Duguid (Mott MacDonald) discussing the Northern Hub, Mike Tonkin & Anna Liu (Tonkin Liu) explaining their winning bridge design competition entry for Salford Meadows, Peter Miller (Severfields) from Bolton’s world class steel fabricators and Chorlton based structural innovator Neil Thomas (Atelier One).

David Climie (Forth Replacement Crossing) will be sharing his long span bridge experience and Alison Watson (Class of Your Own) will hand over to her award winning students who will showcase their ‘Hotel Underground’ entry.

But you don’t have to submit a paper to get involved. The conference features two debates which get particularly interesting with animated discussion amongst the audience and panellists needing no encouragement from the chairs. This year Antony Oliver (Infrastructure Intelligence) will be returning to chair one of the two discussions and Professor Paul Lambert (Mott MacDonald) will be chairing the other, after successfully moderating October’s well-received Journey to Success event in Manchester.

The event aims to promote design and inspire future generations. Hence the majority of delegates are young professionals in the building or bridge industries. It really isn’t like any other conference as, now being a flagship conference for IABSE, it attracts some of the most high profile speakers to present, but at a price that is accessible to young people (only £50 per ticket this year). Always organised by young professionals, I was delighted to be asked to be part of the five-person team (Alison, Hunter, Ian & Jason) to deliver the increasingly popular format in the North of England for the first time. It is great to be a part of expanding IABSE’s reach.

Through events like this, I am getting a strong feeling that IABSE is fast becoming one of the leading organisations for designers, constructors, researchers, clients and others to meet, network and discuss good construction. It is this sharing of knowledge that IABSE, an international organisation with members in over 100 countries worldwide, is all about and what drives us to organise these events.

So encourage your boss to give you the day as CPD. Better yet, enter a paper into the Young Designers Competition (Deadline: 6th February). This is not an event to miss!

Get Your Future of Design North 2015 Ticket

The post IABSE Future of Design North 2015 appeared first on Being Brunel.

]]>
http://www.beingbrunel.com/iabse-future-design-north-2015/feed/ 2
An Engineering Portfolio http://www.beingbrunel.com/engineering-portfolio/ http://www.beingbrunel.com/engineering-portfolio/#respond Fri, 16 Jan 2015 12:26:00 +0000 http://www.beingbrunel.com/?p=3339 Being Brunel | The Civil Engineering Blog

As someone who is forever saying we should do more to share our work with the public; I was a little embarrassed to realise that the idea of a portfolio had never crossed my mind. It's a simple thing; and so much...Read More

The post An Engineering Portfolio appeared first on Being Brunel.

]]>
Being Brunel | The Civil Engineering Blog

Last year I got an email from an engineer called David. After seeing my embarrassment of a video about loving civil engineering, he wrote to tell me that he, too, loved civil engineering. But what he also did, was tell me about a project he’s been working on to share his career in the profession: an online engineering portfolio.

As someone who is forever saying we should do more to share our work with the public; I was a little embarrassed to realise that the idea of a portfolio had never crossed my mind. It’s a simple thing; and so much of our work is visual (sketches, analysis plots, drawings, site photographs) that it really lends itself to the format.

David started his online portfolio as a way of helping civil engineers working in the building and design of bridges. At last count there are 43 projects featured; charting his time with Kier, May Gurney, Alfred McAlpine, Carillion, Birse, Balfour Beaty, Network Rail- with a massive amount of information and photographs. It’s really satisfying to see his photos tracing projects from breaking ground to black-top; in fact, by the time I finished, I was fairly envious of his career!

Being able to browse through 15 years of someone else’s experience in the industry is pretty fascinating in itself; but it also does a lot to promote and celebrate good, honest, civil engineering. Too often, I think, engineering campaigns get tied up in attempting to force the glitz and glamour of “saving the world” and building architectural mega-structures, and forget the actual civil works behind it.

Maybe it’s time we all started a portfolio? But until then:

Check Out DBM Bridges

The post An Engineering Portfolio appeared first on Being Brunel.

]]>
http://www.beingbrunel.com/engineering-portfolio/feed/ 0
Why Do We Hate The Garden Bridge? http://www.beingbrunel.com/hate-garden-bridge/ http://www.beingbrunel.com/hate-garden-bridge/#comments Tue, 13 Jan 2015 13:00:37 +0000 http://www.beingbrunel.com/?p=2998 Being Brunel | The Civil Engineering Blog

For those of you who don't live London adjacent; the capital is remarkably close to getting its very own Garden Bridge- which is exactly what is sounds like: A tiny garden on a strip of artificial land straddling...Read More

The post Why Do We Hate The Garden Bridge? appeared first on Being Brunel.

]]>
Being Brunel | The Civil Engineering Blog

For those of you who don’t live London adjacent; the capital is remarkably close to getting its very own Garden Bridge– which is exactly what is sounds like: A tiny garden on a strip of artificial land straddling the Thames. While it remains controversial across the general public domain, the people who hate it the most- appear to be engineers.

With one of the main drivers being the massive engineering firm Arup, the project has the shape of something I’ve said civil engineers should be doing- taking control and pioneering the development of our built environment. And while it’s tempting to explain away these feelings as the cliché hatred engineers are supposed to harbour for anything that exhibits form before function- this week I’ve decided to take Darth’s advice and search my own feelings; to work out just why I hate that garden bridge…

It’s Not A Bridge, and It’s Not A Park

Not every noun should be trusted; peanuts are not nuts, NeverEnding Story has an end and the Garden Bridge isn’t a bridge. Ian Firth, of IABSE fame, has gone on record with the fantastic quote that, as a bridge, it serves neither artistic nor practical criteria; which I wholeheartedly agree with. You can’t really use it if your intention is simply to cross the river; it doesn’t have the capacity to cater for the peak commuter load of today- let alone the future city.

But if you admit it’s not a bridge; and looking back at their Future of Design talk last year, it’s clear it’s not designed to be– these criticisms start to fall down. It’s a tourist attraction. It is not, and this is the second key point, a park- it’s a garden. You can’t cycle across it (famously), form groups or (I suspect) even jog across it- but then; you can’t do that at the Eden Project– can you? Taken as a garden for perusal, that just so happens to span across the river, it starts to look a bit better.

It’s Publicly Funded

Accepting that it is not a piece of infrastructure, however, does raise the question; why are we paying for it. The official figure for the bridge is around £175m. Of that TfL are forking out £30m of their already stretched budget to contribute; while the treasury is effectively suspending tax on the construction by adding another £30m- again, against a backdrop of austerity. There’s also a danger that we’ll be hit by a £3.5m annual maintenance liability; the country is always the ultimate underwriter.

The rest is privately funded by investors who want to ‘give London a gift‘ through the Garden Bridge Trust. It’s worth noting, however, that as a charity, there’s a tax avoidance advantage to giving- arguably making the price paid by the public even higher through the lost corporation tax. Despite the public assistance, however, the bridge essentially remains private property– no guaranteed right of way, with closures for sponsored parties.

In an odd way it might have been better if the bridge was ticketed- at least that’d give it a more honest purpose. It would definitely reduce complaints from the rest of the country beyond the capital, who are facing a bill for a luxury they might never see. The London Eye provides a fantastic example of a private entity giving back to the surroundings- with the Southbank Centre receiving £500’000 yearly in rent from the structure. Making it free by getting us to prepay for our tickets under the heading “infrastructure” is arguably the most controversial bit of it all.

It’s Needlessly Expensive

At £25’000/m2, you could get ten bridges and forty parks for the same price. But, returning to my original point- that it’s neither a park, nor a bridge, but a tourist attraction; the comparison isn’t as clear cut- why would private investors want to link themselves with 10 ordinary bridges or 40ha of blank green space across the country? At least half of the money doesn’t exist without something special.

What is important, though, is that independent estimates suggest the bridge could be built for a third of the cost. Although trust chair Paul Morrell replied to the claims churlishly blaming costs on “a long list of issues that you really do need to be working on the project to understand”; worryingly stating that the unusual decision to clad the bridge in “maintenance free” (a term all good engineers should fear) cupro-nickel was the term of a donation (which, it’s fair to assume, doesn’t cover the whole cost).

His response belies that this is a structure where value engineering just hasn’t been applied. This would be fine if the private structure didn’t require £60m of public money to fund (which, by the way, would cover the latest cuts on children’s mental health services); but as a profession we owe it to the tax payer (at least) to do our best to reduce the burden our works place on them, remember- ‘an engineer can do for a penny, what any fool can do for a pound…’ Even if you average the two estimates, you get something that doesn’t need to be publicly funded any more…

We’ve Been Told We Want It

The bridge, in its current incantation, began life as a competition run by TfL for an iconic scheme to act as a landmark that supports economic activity, and provide commuters at Waterloo options. It was a scheme initiated by the brains behind the Eremites cable car; possibly London’s only under-utilised piece of infrastructure. And the Garden Bridge won it.

As someone who walks past the site of the new bridge every day, I’ve never thought “well, wouldn’t be it nice to have a garden here…” In fact, it feels very much like Joanna Lumley and Co. have simply decided to build it- and therefore it’ll get built: planning permission seems to be being given at a remarkable rate– despite public uncertainty and the massive impact of the structure.

The truth of the matter is, however, that should it get built- it’s hard to imagine people not using it. Sure, the commuters will probably avoid it, but every tourist will end up meandering along the scenic route. The business case for the bridge makes an interesting read, quoting a return of 3.5 for the bridge; and while it sounds a little ill founded to me, I can’t deny that the Garden Bridge would be a great attraction to add to London’s arsenal…

It’s In An Odd Location

Why there was a tender to increase the options for people walking from Waterloo station is a bit of a mystery- it’s at the most densely bridged part of the Thames, and putting the bridge there threatens the view of St Pauls, which London holds oddly sacrosanct. As someone who walks across it every day- it’s not an unmanageably busy route, and it’s also not really in an area that needs economic development; the North Bank might be quiet, but it’s rich- the South Bank is a cultural hub for the area with everything from art galleries to pop-up theatres!

There are plenty of stretches along the river that are crying out for bridges and a bit of redevelopment- and it seems a shame to waste this scheme along a length that really doesn’t need it. A lot of detractors mention the uncrossed spans- but these are mostly at residential areas and are unlikely to really warrant an iconic structure. That said, something just outside the London Bridge area, or alongside Battersea could arguably be set to gain from the attraction.

So why do I hate the Garden Bridge? Well, it’s because people keep trying to pretend it’s a piece of public infrastructure; but it’s really not. And that’s OK. It’s a private theme park (nay, garden), and it is an interesting one- more a piece of art than a well engineered structure; but one I’d happily have paid £5.00 to wonder across. If they’d just have been honest about that at the start, then we would have ended up with a unique attraction (hopefully in a better location) without the bitter taste in our mouth.

The post Why Do We Hate The Garden Bridge? appeared first on Being Brunel.

]]>
http://www.beingbrunel.com/hate-garden-bridge/feed/ 9
Saving Brunel’s Other Bridge http://www.beingbrunel.com/saving-brunels-bridge/ http://www.beingbrunel.com/saving-brunels-bridge/#respond Mon, 05 Jan 2015 13:00:02 +0000 http://www.beingbrunel.com/?p=3211 Being Brunel | The Civil Engineering Blog

Did you know that most important Brunel (of Being Brunel fame) bridge in Bristol lays abandoned; rotting away along the side of a canal? Although he wasn't born there- they city owes a lot of his engineering efforts, and...Read More

The post Saving Brunel’s Other Bridge appeared first on Being Brunel.

]]>
Being Brunel | The Civil Engineering Blog

Did you know that most important Brunel (of Being Brunel fame) bridge in Bristol lays abandoned; rotting away along the side of a dock? Although he wasn’t born there- the city owes a lot to his engineering efforts, and is arguably the home most celebrated for his achievements. The only abandoned Brunel structure in Bristol, this Grade 2* bridge is now listed as being at extreme risk on the English Heritage Buildings at Risk Register.

Before you run off to check the papers for news of the Clifton Suspension Bridge’s collapse, let me clarify- I’m talking about Brunel’s other bridge; the Howard’s Lock Swivel Bridge. Unlike its more celebrated cousin, which was largely a posthumous achievement completed by William Barlow and Sir John Hawkshaw; the Swivel bridge was completed 15 years earlier- under the direct supervision of the man himself (although let’s not neglect to mention Brereton– who was probably responsible for most of the detailed design- Brunel was very much a Blue Sky thinker…)

The Swivel Bridge

Before I continue, I should mention that there’s an exhibition on this structure at the Bristol Central Library from the 5th of January to the 15th of February; which will be much more comprehensive than my attempt!

But splitting hairs about the level of IK’s involvement isn’t what makes this bridge so very important; it’s an early example of a wrought iron plate girder bridge, and his first tubular flanged bridge. In the swivel bridge, to the initiated eye, we can see Brunel’s engineering development of plated girders and and tubular flanges that were echoed throughout his later career in the likes of the Royal Albert Bridge, or the Chepstow Railway Bridge.

Commissioned in 1844 the 33.7m long (23m nose) 68 tonne bridge was designed and built by Brunel and his staff in 1849 to carry traffic over the new south entrance lock (also by Brunel) to the Cumberland Basin. Originally rotated through a hand turned crank (like ye-olde train turntables), the swivel was replaced with a hydraulic mechanism in 1901. Perhaps most interestingly, the bridge was shortened and relocated to it’s current location at the north entrance in 1872-3, and then in 1875-6 a replica (differentiated only by it’s more modern section sizes) was built in the original position; presumably just to confuse future historians. Until the M5 was built it remained on a primary route; but in 1968, after the construction of the Plimsoll Bridge, it was decommissioned, and rotated one final time to be laid to rest under the new bridge.

Brunel’s Other Bridge

Fantastically, however, a group (aptly named Brunel’s Other Bridge) have been working to save this monumental structure. The history of the bridge’s restoration has been an interesting one; it was almost saved by the Sustrans scheme in 2008, however the council were reluctant to restore the bridge (repairing and maintaining old infrastructure is a substantial risk). After a failed lottery funding attempt by Bristol’s Cycling City Team, however, the Clifton & Hotwells Improvement Society, Bristol Industrial Archaeological Society and Avon Industrial Building Trust decided to move forward, on the 12th of April 2013, and repair the bridge themselves, independent (but with agreement from) the council.

Since 2013 They have been raising funds and carrying out work to repair the structure using volunteers. This year they’ll be doing everything from paint analysis to jacking up the bridge! You can see the sorts of stuff they’ve been up to in their photos… Of course, none of this is cheap; and the easiest way you can help save our engineering heritage is by making a donation.

The best bit, to me at least, is that if you fancy chipping in; you can- no experience needed. Personally the chance to get my hands dirty and ground my life of analytical design with some honest labour is good enough; but the opportunity to say I’ve worked on one of Brunel’s structures… well, that’s impossible to turn down. So I’ll be offering to give up a weekend sometime this year (expect a chuffed article to come), and, if you want to move off of the theory and start doing the practical (surely this counts as C1-5), here are the provisional dates for 2015:

  • February 21-22
  • March 21-22
  • April 18-19
  • May 16-17
  • June 20-21
  • July 18-19
  • September 19-20
  • October 17-18

Click Here To Help Save Brunel’s Other Bridge!

This article owes an awful lot to Grace’s Guide, which is an amazing resource for industrial structures.

The post Saving Brunel’s Other Bridge appeared first on Being Brunel.

]]>
http://www.beingbrunel.com/saving-brunels-bridge/feed/ 0